So, we're not necessarily proud we watched these, but as you can tell from the fact that we watched the sequel after watching the first one, they were fun! And as they say, there's no such thing as a guilty pleasure, so damnit, I recommend them. In fact, if there was a third one, I'd watch that too! You have to stick with the first one for a little bit, because it starts out rather obnoxiously, not just because the main character (who, for unknown reasons, is called "Tree") is herself obnoxious, but because she's a 30 year-old playing an undergraduate, and the general depiction of undergraduate life seems very stale and unreal. However, once she gets killed for the first time (after you've sort of been rooting for it, to be honest), things improve. The concept is slasher film-crossed-with-Groundhog Day, which doesn't sound either original or entertaining, but is made so by the surprisingly good writing and performances, especially by main actress Jessica Rothe (who, it seems, has always played younger than her age) who is fully committed to the indignities that the film throws at her.
And, despite its slasher premise, both films manage to be surprisingly non-cloyingly sweet and genuinely comedic for large stretches (while also throwing in some jump scares). It doesn't have the nasty aftertaste that, say, Scream has. Anyway, Tree is stuck in her birthday, which she hates because it was also her mother's birthday, and she died three years ago. So she is avoiding her father, who wants to meet for lunch, and is not really enthused by the fact that her sorority (yes, that's part of the stale-depiction-of-college-life aspect) is planning a secret party for her. But she keeps getting killed by someone in a grotesque baby mask
(which is the school mascot - the absurdity of which is voiced out loud by a character in the sequel) and this then wakes her up again in the bed in the dorm room of Carter, a boy (not a fraternity member) who took her home when she passed out drunk at a party the night before. Over the course of the first film, she gradually falls for him, as he is obviously kind and decent, and, as in Groundhog Day, she becomes a better person (and comes to grips with how she's become hardened as a way to deal with the death of her mother) and thus to appreciate his qualities. She becomes convinced that the person stalking her is a murderer who is initially a prisoner at the hospital where her roommate, and also her married biology professor, with whom she is having an affair, work. And [SPOILER] indeed, when the baby mask finally comes off, it's his face. And she has him at her mercy and can bump him off and, she believes, get out of the time loop by surviving the day, but by then he has already killed Carter, and she decides she has to reboot things one more time to save Carter first. But at the same time, one wrinkle that this story adds to Groundhog is that each death leaves her weaker, and she carries the scars of each into the next day.
Will she succeed? Well, duh, there's a sequel. And, having watched the first one, you might wonder what there is to do a sequel about, as it doesn't really leave any loose ends. And as the sequel starts, it looks like it's going to be about Ryan Phan, who has a recurring cameo in the original bursting in to the dorm room asking if Carter managed to get off with Tree, only using an obscene derogatory term for her. Turns out Carter had slept in Ryan's bed and made him sleep in his car (improbably parked on a side-road just off campus) which, Ryan complained, smelled of "Hot Pockets and feet". But then Ryan is killed by a psycho in a baby mask and he has to relive his day.
However, once he has described this in earshot of Tree, she quickly fills him in on what's happening. And Ryan also works out that the cause of all this is a science experiment that he and two other buddies are working on,
which becomes the focus of the rest of the film, which is much more science-fictiony than the original, which left the explanation of the time loop open. It also introduces the element of parallel dimensions, because it turns out that Tree has been hurled into one, one where (ugh) Carter is the boyfriend of the supremely shallow leader of her sorority, Danielle, but (yay) her mother is still alive! So she has to choose between having Carter and having her Mother. The serial killer crops up again (even though he's not the stabber that attacks Ryan) and several characters switch roles from good to evil or vice-versa. While the first movie openly name-checks Groundhog Day, this one does so with Back to the Future Part 2, because, like that film, it recycles events from the first in a more complicated way (in both cases the joke is that Tree has not seen either film, to Carter's amazement). Also the second film seems to make an effort to bring the non-white characters into more central characters, because the first one only had them as cameos. Surprisingly the sequel genuinely works, expanding the "universe" of the first one and, while there is a danger in explaining the mystery of the first one, it doesn't spoil it (and has very good call backs to it). So, if you're in the mood for some lowbrow entertainment that still doesn't insult your intelligence, check these out! (I just remembered that the much (and rightly) praised Russian Doll also uses the Groundhog Day premise, as does a film from last year called Palm Springs that a lot of people really liked (but that is on Hulu, so we can't see it) but HDD beat 'em to it (in fact, HDD2U came out at the same time as Russian Doll). I suppose that just shows that Groundhog Day unearthed one of the few story archetypes that hadn't been around for centuries. Was it really the first? Apparently not.)