Just as one is supposed to watch horror films in October, someone coined the portmanteau "Noirvember" for the imperative to watch film noirs this month. It's the right month for it, too, or it would be normally if the world weren't ending in fire, as the shadows grow longer and the nights draw in. Now, as with any label, there is disagreement over what exactly makes up a film noir, and corresponding disagreement over which films qualify. It is a category not defined simply by subject matter or style of filming, but period, that period being largely the 40s, the doom-laden spirit of World War II contributing greatly to the nihilism of the films. We've seen most of the true classics (Double Indemnity, Out of the Past, Asphalt Jungle, The Killers, Detour, The Big Heat, etc.) but it came to my attention that this one was often cited as the very first Film Noir, and we hadn't seen it, so here we are.
One common denominator for many of the Noirs is a European director (usually escaping the Nazis), who brings with them the influence of the German Expressionist films
(sometimes, as with Fritz Lang, because they actually directed some), and in particular, the stark lighting (Chiaroscuro),
but also the slightly melodramatic edge. These are to be had in spades in this little number, with the added bonus of the presence of the mighty Peter Lorre (along with the always put-upon Elisha Cook Jr,
who was to join Lorre in The Maltese Falcon the following year) playing a more extreme version of his M character, in a film directed by the Russian-Jewish Boris Inkster, who had worked with Eisenstein. But the film is very much free of the fatalistic ending that I take to be a true mark of Film Noir (and fatalism in general, most famously evinced by the reveal at the beginnings of Sunset Boulevard and DOA that the protagonist is already dead), almost cartoonishly so. (It's almost David Lynchian in its perkiness after the Sturm und Drang that has preceded it.)
But is it worth watching? I would say so, even some of the sneerings of the contemporary American critics are on-point. They thought it a bit "overwrought" (and a very drawn-out dream sequence, involving the main character, a newspaperman whose testimony has put the hapless Elisha Cook Jr. on death row imagining a similar fate for himself
does test one's patience, even if the visuals are great), and noted the contrast between the "artiness" of the direction and the humdrum-ness of the dialog and acting (outside of our two soon-to-be Falcon co-stars).
The film is bookended by the female lead (a perfectly decent but unremarkable Margaret Tallichet, for whom this was her most noted role) eating at a packed lunch counter, reserving the seat next to her, much to the annoyance of other customers. Finally her beau (John McGuire), a newspaperman, shows up
with the good news that they can afford to get married (currently they are both staying in somewhat seedy flop-houses, she with a female roommate,
he with annoying neighbors, especially the strangely-named Mr. Meng)
and move in together, because he's received a $12-a-week raise for writing a story about his own role as the witness in a murder case. She's upset at the news, because she worries about him being the one to convict the "kid". And indeed, she has to run out of the courtroom later that day as Cook Jr. screams that he didn't do it after the jury convicts him. But, as our hero Jim asks, what was he supposed to do? He did come into the diner and find the kid hanging over the corpse of the owner. (In fact, he was coming to see Jim because Jim had loaned him money for food and he wanted to repay him, and he had just discovered the corpse.)
Our heroine, Jane, is so distraught she doesn't want to see Jim, and he is left to wander home in the dark. He spots a weird looking guy (Lorre, of course) hanging around his building's stoop (which is right opposite the place the murder happened), and later that night he sees him scuttling about on the floor his room is (third, of course - see film title).
And then he discovers the annoying neighbor, the one that many people have heard him (Jim) say he'd like to kill, with his throat slashed in bed. He decides he needs to go on the lam. Jane talks him out of it, and he tells the police, and gives a description of Lorre (bulgy eyes and a long white scarf is about it - I thought of Kirk Douglas's character in 20,000 Leagues Under The Sea referring to Lorre's "soft boiled egg eyes") while they eye him with extreme suspicion. Meanwhile Jane takes it upon herself to comb the neighborhood looking for the same character, only to have him sit down next to her as she is recovering over a cup of coffee at that lunch counter. He is buying raw hamburger to feed a stray dog that followed him, just to go to show that there's a nice side even to homicidal maniacs (who have apparently escaped from an institution and will kill anyone whom they think will shop him to said institution). Jane's sleuthing puts her directly in harms way, and Lorre's character is definitely getting suspicious,
and meanwhile not one but two innocent men are at risk of being executed...
Anyway, I dispute its noir status, but it's definitely worth the watch, even if it is unintentionally funny at times. Lorre's sheer presence cuts through that funny, however, as he exudes real menace.







-3975157676.jpg)














































